top of page

Case Study · Pharmacy Cosmetics

How AI, TELL ME! Identified a Global Pharma Cosmetics Brand's Biggest AI Search Growth Gap and Built Its GEO Strategy

AI Search Visibility & Citation Analysis for a Global Pharmacy Cosmetics Brand

SERVICES

AEO & GEO Monitoring · Category-Level AI Search Visibility Analysis · First-Party & Third-Party Citation Analysis · GEO Strategy

CLIENT

Global Pharmacy Cosmetics Brand

INDUSTRY

Pharmacy Cosmetics & Personal Care

MARKET

United Kingdom

PROGRAMME

Multi-stage AI Search Audit

Results at a Glance

44%

AI search presence across core face-care monitoring

75%

Presence across oily & acne-prone skin queries

#1.3

Average position when the brand appeared in core recommendations

640+

AI-generated responses analysed across the programme

Category-level GEO strategy

Clear priorities defined for core, emerging and underrepresented product areas

The Challenge

The client is a global pharmacy cosmetics brand with products spanning several skincare and personal-care categories.

 

Initial monitoring showed a sharp difference across the portfolio. Core facial-care queries generated regular recommendations, particularly around oily and acne-prone skin, sun protection and uneven skin tone. Baby care appeared much less frequently, while hair and scalp-care queries produced only isolated brand recommendations.

 

AI, TELL ME! analysed the portfolio at category and consumer-need level to identify where the brand already had an established AI search position and where relevance still needed to be built.

 

The analysis also covered the sources behind those recommendations: which company-owned pages were being cited, which third-party domains appeared across AI answers and whether citation presence translated into actual brand recommendations.

The Baseline

More than 640 AI-generated responses were analysed across multiple monitoring studies covering core facial care and adjacent product areas.

 

The analysis covered:

  • Brand presence and individual mentions.
  • Average recommendation position.
  • Performance by category and consumer need.
  • Competitor presence across the same queries.
  • Company-owned pages used as cited sources.
  • Third-party domains appearing across AI answers.
  • Queries where the brand was present or absent.

 

Core facial care was the strongest part of the portfolio. The brand appeared in around 44% of monitored responses and held an average position of approximately #1.3 when recommended.

 

Results varied considerably within the category. Oily & acne-prone skin reached around 75% presence, while sun protection and uneven skin tone also showed high recommendation coverage.

 

Outside core facial care, visibility dropped considerably. Baby care remained in the low single digits overall, while hair and scalp care produced only isolated appearances.

 

The sharp drop beyond the strongest product areas became the key input for the GEO strategy.

What Was Done

1

Category-level AEO / GEO monitoring

AI, TELL ME! monitored AI-generated recommendations separately across core and adjacent product areas. This exposed differences in recommendation coverage that would have been lost inside a single brand-wide visibility metric.

2

AI search visibility was analysed by consumer need

Monitoring was segmented by specific needs, including oily and acne-prone skin, sun protection, uneven skin tone, dry and sensitive skin and anti-aging. Baby care and hair and scalp care were analysed at the same level of detail, giving a direct view of where AI recommendation coverage was already established and where it remained limited.

3

Recommendation prominence was measured

Brand presence was reviewed together with ranking position. Within core facial care, the brand was usually placed near the top of the recommendation set, with an average position of approximately #1.3. This separated meaningful recommendation presence from incidental mentions.

4

First-party and third-party citations were analysed

Company-owned pages were compared with the external domains cited across AI-generated answers. Company content appeared as a cited source in around 44% of core face-care responses. Our team also reviewed the wider citation landscape to identify which source types repeatedly influenced recommendations. Pharmacy and retail websites, medical and public-health sources, specialist publications, health and beauty content and manufacturer websites all appeared regularly. The analysis uncovered an additional gap: company content could be cited without the brand appearing in the final recommendation, while some brand recommendations relied mainly on third-party sources.

5

Category-specific GEO priorities were defined

The monitoring and citation data were translated into different priorities across the portfolio. Established areas required broader query coverage, high recommendation positions and greater use of first-party content. Underrepresented areas needed stronger category relevance, supporting content and presence across the external sources already shaping AI answers.

HIGH LEVEL OUTLOOK

Strong Core Visibility, Clear Expansion Gap

AI, TELL ME!'s analysis showed that the brand already had a solid AI search position across core facial care.


Oily & acne-prone skin was the strongest monitored area at approximately 75% presence. Sun protection and uneven skin tone also showed high recommendation coverage, and the brand typically appeared near the top when included.


That strength did not extend across the full portfolio.


Baby care had much lower overall presence, while hair and scalp care appeared only occasionally. The data pointed to two different priorities: expand an established position in core facial care and build category relevance in areas where AI systems had not yet formed the same association with the brand.

First-Party & Third-Party Citation Findings

First-party content already contributed meaningfully to core facial-care answers, appearing as a cited source in around 44% of monitored responses.


Pharmacy, medical, editorial and specialist health and beauty websites were also regularly used to support AI-generated recommendations.


Our team found that citation presence and recommendation presence did not always move together. In some cases, company content supported the answer without the brand being recommended. In others, the brand appeared through information drawn mainly from third-party sources.


That distinction shaped the source strategy: increase first-party citation coverage in established areas while building both recommendation relevance and source presence in weaker ones.

GEO Strategy

Based on the monitoring and citation findings, AI, TELL ME! developed a category-level GEO strategy for the portfolio.


Core facial care was treated as an established area, with emphasis on broader query coverage, maintaining high recommendation positions and increasing first-party citation coverage.


Baby care and hair and scalp care required a different plan, focused on building category relevance, supporting content and presence across the third-party sources already influencing AI-generated recommendations.


The final roadmap gave the client three clear priorities: protect and expand existing AI search visibility in core categories, build relevance in underrepresented product areas and increase the contribution of company-owned content to AI answers.


Future monitoring will measure progress against those specific priorities.

In marketing since 2009. In AI search since it became a category.

Our team has worked with international brands across SaaS, e-commerce, fintech and professional services for over fifteen years, originally as ContActive Tech Communications.

Brands_AITM!_.png

Today, that same senior team applies its strategic and technical expertise to answer engine optimisation, generative engine optimisation, and AI search visibility.

If AEO and GEO are on your radar, we would be glad to talk.

Talk to a human, get GEO recommendations and more. →

bottom of page